paul keatingIn 2004 a relatively small number of container ships still graced Sydney Harbour and Botany Bay was being eyed off once again for development considered inappropriate on the Harbour shores.  At a forum in Sydney’s Town Hall titled “Should Sydney Harbour remain a working Harbour?”  Paul Keating lined up with the then Tourism Taskforce boss Chris Brown and others to argue against container shipping on the Harbour.  It was inappropriate to have ‘tarmac like structures’ in the Harbour, he said.  And by default he was also arguing that they should go to Botany Bay.  Which they did.   As a result only a small part of the Banksmeadow shoreline (where Joseph Banks famously walked) remains – heavily eroded and polluted.

After ridding the Harbour of container ships and the Miller’s Point terminal the area was re-named Barangaroo and a Design Excellence Review Panel under the Chairmanship of Keating set up to deliver an inspirational plan for the area.    The winning design from Philip Thallis was discarded and in 2009 Keating was arguing for a design that included the reinstatement of the original shoreline.   More recently  Keating has found praise for the Casino project and so too has NSW Opposition Spokesman, Luke Foley.

Luke-Foley-NSW-Shadow-Environment-MinisterYet in response to the recent release of the Royal Botanic Gardens and Domain Trust Master Plan both Keating and Foley  have been critical.    Foley doesn’t want easier access with ferry and train stops.  Instead he proposes stopping all vehicles including tour buses at the roundabout near Boy Charlton pool.  The Botanic Gardens is a State-owned asset with a mission “to inspire the appreciation and conservation of plants”.  Foley states that the focus “should always be on plant science and providing a green space for people who live and work in Sydney.”  The master plan does provide opportunities for improving the focus on science with a purpose built Herbarium, an expanded Library, more space for educational activities, and better interpretation and engagement.  The ‘green spaces’ and the rest of the estate shouldn’t be limited to those fortunate enough to live or work close by.  Under Foley’s proposal access would become more difficult, particularly for visitors with restricted mobility and the new Herbarium would not be built.  He proposes bush regeneration for Mrs Macquarie’s Point but this would be better carried out in our pest ridden National Parks, particularly around Botany Bay.





One Response to “For Labor pollies Botany Bay is not worthy but on Sydney Harbour it’s got to be ‘natural’.”
  1. admin says:

    Prince Paul would do better to argue for Botany Bay (Letters to the Editor, SMH, 15 September 2009).

    Paul Keating once represented the people of Bankstown in the Botany Bay catchment, but today he champions the romantic notion of reconstructing the shoreline around Millers Point to resemble early colonial maps and paintings. By contrast, the shoreline in Banksmeadow, Botany Bay, is currently being reconfigured and public access reduced by 80 per cent to accommodate the containers and cranes that Keating considered so inappropriate on Sydney Harbour.

    You quote him as saying: ”Designers have a strange disjunction from and distrust of nature.” But it is Keating who suffers a disconnection, applying a limited postcard view of the environment.

    The present shoreline around Barangaroo pays homage to a long and proud workers’ history, which began with the operation of Australia’s first windmill and continued through to the wharves. The Boy from Bankstown would be of more use if he returned to his roots. Nature needs saving in Botany Bay, not Barangaroo.

  2. how to get rid of a stye says:

    Fine way of describing, and nice article to obtain facts
    on the topic of my presentation subject, which i am going to convey in college.

  3. Arlen Strobeck says:

    Another thing I have noticed is that often for many people, poor credit is the results of circumstances over and above their control. By way of example they may happen to be saddled by having an illness and as a consequence they have more bills going to collections. It could be due to a job loss and the inability to do the job. Sometimes divorce process can truly send the finances in a downward direction. Thanks sharing your notions on this website.

  4. LAPEROUSE » For Labor pollies Botany Bay is not worthy but on Sydney Harbour it says:

    Jess Guilliams

    I found a great…

  5. wallpaper keroppi says:

    Hey, I think your website might be having browser compatibility issues.
    When I look at your blog site in Ie, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer,
    it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick
    heads up! Other then that, terrific blog!

  6. Mitsenkodag says:

    online stripes online kaufen

    bed5 we like it 5mg online online

  7. Mitsenkodag says:

    uk online visa

    bed5 only now online femele

  8. Alibinadag says:

    qual melhor onlineo online

    b1c3 como conseguir online gratis

  9. Leonidadag says:

    viagra pro france

    [url=]buy viagra[/url]

    cheap viagrail cialis one a day

    [url=]buy cialis[/url]

    canadian cialis

  10. Leonidadag says:

    original viagra for sale

    [url=]buy viagra online[/url]

    buy viagra onlinecialis for sale online india

    [url=]buy cialis[/url]

    canadian cialis

  11. Roalddag says:

    online 5mg wirkstoff

    86c3 acheter du online cipla

  12. Raymundo Prows says:

    thanks for sharing this information..have shared this link with others keep posting such information..

  13. Ignatijdag says:

    online generika paypal

    a541 online libre en lnea

  14. Ignatijdag says:

    online online over counter

    a541 online original vs onlineo

  15. Ignatijdag says:

    online on line sales us

    a541 best price online 10 mg

  16. Sabindag says:

    online achat libre

    8d82 online manufacturers

  17. Sabindag says:

    picture of online pill

    8d82 online online medicamentos

  18. Sabindag says:

    online and three day delivery

    8d82 online online into canada

  19. Sabindag says:

    a628 compren viagra para barato

    [url=]buy viagra online[/url]
    generic viagra

    pfizer viagra vgr 100

  20. Sabindag says:

    online online nhs

    8d82 online bestellen ebay

  21. Sabindag says:

    online cheap real online online

    8d82 day usa online next

  22. Selinadag says:

    online veloc

    f4ff enter site rx online online

  23. Selinadag says:

    cheapest chemist to online online

    f4ff compren la pldora online

  24. Selinadag says:

    ff5d online pharmacy viagra reviews

    [url=]viagra cheap[/url]
    viagra generic

    viagra price in kenya

  25. Alinkadag says:

    online shopping

    0734 esiste online per donn

  26. Selifandag says:

    precio de 40 mg online

    5978 online cost walgreen

  27. Selifandag says:

    where to online online online

    5978 online street value

  28. Selifandag says:

    b783 we use it how much cialis

    [url=]buy cialis[/url]
    cheap cialis

    cialis street value

  29. Grettadag says:

    online online purchase uk

    be77 online yaho

  30. Avdotyadag says:

    dollar online

    3bc5 online online usa sears online

  31. Avdotyadag says:

    mejor farmacia online online

    3bc5 online receta medica

  32. Stavrdag says:

    without online online script

    3568 farmacia de online rx

  33. Arijdag says:

    online acquisto propecia

    a93a venta de online en espaa

Leave a Reply